Seton Hall Prep has a knack for showing up in big games. This one, however, sets the bar at a new high.

The Pirates stunned the entire Garden State and beyond with arguably the upset of the 2020 season by knocking off St. Peter’s Prep, the state’s No. 1 ranked team, in a 26-25 overtime marathon in West Orange.

Myles Thomason caught the game-tying touchdown pass in overtime and Nick Conforti’s extra point proved to be the game-winner in a game for the ages.

JSZ’s Jay Cook has all the highlights and postgame reaction from one of the most thrilling wins you’ll see all year:

Sponsor Shoutout!

Jersey Sports Zone’s coverage of all Seton Hall Prep athletics is brought to you by “One-on-One with Steve Adubato.”